Fall in love with treats from For Goodness Cakes!
Please order at least 5 days prior to
desired pick-up or drop-off date.
All of our regular cakes, cupcakes, and other items
will be available upon request!
For any other designs or item inquiries, please contact us!

 

Christina’s Classic Sugar Cookies

Our delicious, not too sweet, thick, and soft sugar cookie, garnished
with a choice of sanding sugar or royal icing

Cookies Finished with Only Sanding Sugar

Hearts
Small/Medium
$6.75 each
(One Dozen Deal for $80)
Large
$8 each
(One Dozen Deal for $95)

Cookies Finished with Royal Icing and/or Sprinkles

Conversation Heart & Sprinkle Heart Cookies
Small/Medium
$6.75 each
(One Dozen Deal for $80)
Large
$8 each
(One Dozen Deal for $95)

‘We Go Together’ Cookies
Small/Medium
$7 each
(One Dozen Deal for $83)
Large
$9 each
(One Dozen Deal for $106)

‘Relationship Status’ Cookies
Small/Medium
$7 each
(One Dozen Deal for $83)
Large
$9 each
(One Dozen Deal for $106)

Galentine’s Day/Valentine’s Day Dino Cookies
$8.50 each
(One Dozen Deal for $100)

DIY Sugar Cookie Kit
2 large & 4 small heart shapes of our plain, classic sugar cookies,
accompanied with 3 bags of different colored royal icing,
and a heaping handful of Valentine’s Day sprinkles.
$40
(Additional cookies, icing colors, and sprinkles can be added for additional costs)

Custom Valentine’s Day Cookies
Customize your cookies’ colors, shapes, sizes, and design
Pricing starts at $8.00 each
(Pricing dependent on message details/complexity of design)
(Can’t decide? Choose baker’s choice! Trust me, you’ll love what you get!)

Individually wrapped in our compostable bag and raffia bow
Additional 15¢ per cookie

 

Christina’s Cake Pops

A mixture of cake in icing all rolled into one bite-size treat!

Heart Pops
Heart-shaped pops dipped in
colorful chocolate coating and finished with sprinkles
$3.50 each
(One Dozen Deal for $40)

Classic Round Pops
Regular, round shape with an assortment of
colorful chocolate coating and finished with sprinkles
$3.00 each
(One Dozen Deal for $35)

For cake pop flavors, please click here

Christina’s Classic Cakes & Cupcakes

Cakes

Heart-Shaped 6″ Cake
Pricing Starts at $60
(Price Dependent on Chosen Flavor)
Available in the following flavors:
Available in all flavors except The Fruit Basket & The Spice of Life

Heart-Shaped 8″ Cake
Pricing Starts at $75
(Price Dependent on Chosen Flavor)
Available in the following flavors:
Available in all flavors except The Fruit Basket & The Spice of Life

Cupcakes

Valentine’s Cupcakes
Minis: Minimum of 6 per flavor
Regular: Minimum of 6 per flavor
All cupcakes will be garnished with a variety of different
Valentine’s designs, colors, and decorations.
Mini
$3.00 each 
Regular
$4.25 each

For cake & cupcake flavors, click here

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries

One dozen dark chocolate with white chocolate drizzle
$42

One dozen white chocolate with dark chocolate drizzle
$42

One dozen varieties of chocolate-dipped strawberries
$42